Log in Request staff
For providers · Checklist

How to choose a care staffing agency: the 26-point checklist

The questions to ask before you let an agency's staff through your door — covering vetting, CQC evidence, reliability, continuity and cost. With a scorecard you can fill in here or print to compare agencies side by side.

MAP HealthCare Updated 29 September 2026 12-minute read
A care home manager in Bristol reviewing staffing schedules and agency paperwork

When an agency worker walks into your home, they are caring for your residents under your registration. If something goes wrong, the inspector will not ask the agency what happened — they will ask you. That is why choosing a staffing agency is not a purchasing decision. It is a safeguarding decision with a cost attached.

Most agencies will tell you they are compliant, reliable and good value. This checklist is about getting them to show you. It is written for registered managers, deputy managers and operations leads in UK care homes, nursing homes and supported living services, and it works just as well for re-checking the agencies you already use as for choosing a new one.

The short answer

To choose a care staffing agency, check six things — in this order:

  1. How it vets workers — enhanced DBS, right to work, references, NMC registration.
  2. Training and competence — mandatory training in date and grades that match skills.
  3. What you receive before each shift — a worker profile you can show an inspector.
  4. Reliability — how shifts are filled, and what happens when someone drops out.
  5. Continuity — whether you can have the same people back.
  6. Money and admin — a clear rate card, approved timesheets and no lock-in.

First: who is accountable for agency staff?

It surprises many new managers, but most care staffing agencies are not registered with the CQC. An agency that only supplies staff to work in your service is an employment business. It is regulated under the Conduct of Employment Agencies and Employment Businesses Regulations 2003 and overseen by the Employment Agency Standards Inspectorate — not by the CQC.

The CQC regulates you. Under the Health and Social Care Act 2008 (Regulated Activities) Regulations 2014, Regulation 18 requires you to deploy enough suitably qualified, competent and experienced staff, and Regulation 19 requires everyone working in your service to be fit and proper for the role. Agency workers are included. You can rely on the agency's checks — but only if you can evidence them.

◆ What this means in practice

The agency does the checks. You keep the proof. A good agency makes the second part effortless; a poor one leaves you chasing paperwork after the shift has already happened.

The scorecard

Work through the 26 questions with the agency — on a call, in a meeting or by email. Tick each one they answer well and can back up in writing. Your score and any missing essentials update as you go.

!Questions marked Essential are non-negotiable. An agency that can't evidence every essential isn't ready to supply your service, whatever its score.
1

Vetting every worker

0 / 6

The checks behind Regulation 19 and Schedule 3 — and the heart of your inspection evidence.

2

Training & competence

0 / 4

A clear DBS proves someone is safe to be in the building. Training proves they can do the job.

3

What you receive before each shift

0 / 3

This is the paperwork your inspector asks you for — so it should reach you before the worker does.

4

Reliability

0 / 5

Everything above matters only if someone actually turns up.

5

Continuity

0 / 3

Residents — especially those living with dementia — do better with faces they know. So do your permanent staff.

6

Money & admin

0 / 5

Clear pricing and clean admin are signs of a well-run agency — and they save your team hours every month.

0 / 26
Your verdict
Start ticking the questions the agency answers well.

Essentials still to confirm: all 6.

The printed version is a blank scorecard for comparing up to three agencies side by side. Your ticks are saved on this device only.

Email me my scorecard

Get your ticks, score and the essentials still to confirm in your inbox — handy to forward to your operations lead.

We'll email your copy and keep your name, care home and email as a record of the request. What you entered in the tool is only sent to you. Privacy policy

Six red flags that should end the conversation

"We'll send the paperwork after."Compliance evidence that arrives after the shift is compliance evidence you didn't have during it.
No PIN, no DBS date for a named worker.If they can't tell you about the person they're sending, they don't know.
Rates quoted only over the phone."It depends" is not a rate card. Neither is a figure you can't find later.
A different person turns up.Swapping a named worker without telling you is a safeguarding failure, not an admin slip.
Nobody answers out of hours.Try the number at night before you rely on it at night.
Pressure to sign on the first call.Exclusivity or minimum spend before a single shift is a sign they need you more than you need them.

What your inspector may ask about agency staff

Inspections vary, but questions about agency workers tend to come back to the same handful of themes. Use the scorecard to make sure you have an answer ready for each.

The inspector asksWhat good evidence looks like
How do you know agency staff are safe to work here?A profile on file for every agency worker, showing DBS, right to work, references, training and NMC status — section 3.
How are they inducted?A short, signed local induction on their first shift: fire exits, emergency procedures, residents' key risks, who is in charge.
How do you know they are competent?Grade-matched bookings, in-date training and competency sign-off for tasks like medication — section 2.
How do you decide staffing levels?A dependency tool reviewed as residents' needs change, and a record of how gaps were covered. There is no fixed legal ratio in England.
How do you keep care consistent?The same agency workers booked repeatedly, with handovers and care plans they already know — section 5.
Put us to the test

How MAP HealthCare answers this checklist

We wrote this checklist, so it's fair you hold us to it. Here's how our platform handles the questions above — and we're happy to evidence any of it in writing.

  • Vetting before any booking — enhanced DBS, right to work, references and, for RGNs, a valid NMC PIN checked against the register. Section 1
  • Expired documents block bookings automatically — a lapsed DBS or out-of-date training removes someone from matching until it's renewed. Section 3
  • Grade-matched in code — only professionals holding the grade you post (HCA, SCA or RGN) can see or accept the shift. Section 2
  • See fill status live — your shift goes to every matching professional at once, and your portal shows the moment it's accepted. Section 4
  • Rebook in one tap — invite the same trusted professional back to the same site, straight from your portal. Section 5
  • Timesheets you approve — professionals submit from the app; you approve in the portal before anything is billed. Section 6
  • No set-up fees — you pay per shift covered, and you can start with a single shift. Section 6

Based in Kingswood, Bristol, since 2015. Read more about how we vet every healthcare professional.

Frequently asked questions

Are care staffing agencies regulated by the CQC?

Usually not. An agency that only supplies staff to work in your service is an employment business, regulated under the Conduct of Employment Agencies and Employment Businesses Regulations 2003 and overseen by the Employment Agency Standards Inspectorate. The CQC regulates your care home, so accountability for safe staffing stays with you. Agencies that deliver care themselves, such as home care agencies, are a different service and are CQC-registered.

Who is responsible for pre-employment checks on agency staff?

The agency carries out the checks, but you remain accountable for who works in your service under Regulation 19 of the Health and Social Care Act 2008 (Regulated Activities) Regulations 2014. You can rely on the agency's checks, provided you get written confirmation of them — typically a worker profile showing identity, DBS, right to work, references, training and, for nurses, NMC registration.

Should I check an agency nurse's NMC PIN myself?

Yes — it takes a minute and is good practice. Search the nurse's PIN on the NMC's online register before their first shift with you and confirm the registration is current with no conditions that affect the role. Registration can change at any time, so recheck regularly for nurses you use often.

What happens to agency rates after 12 weeks?

Under the Agency Workers Regulations 2010, an agency worker who has done the same role with the same hirer for 12 weeks becomes entitled to the same basic pay and working conditions as if you had recruited them directly. That can increase the charge rate, so ask agencies to explain in advance how they handle it.

Need staff in Bristol, Bath or South Gloucestershire?

Vetted HCAs, senior carers and RGNs — posted once, filled live, rebooked in a tap.

Request staff

This article is general guidance for care providers in England and is not legal advice. Regulations and CQC guidance change — check the current position with the CQC, the Employment Agency Standards Inspectorate and the NMC.

Score us against the checklist

Book a single shift, or ask us to take you through how we vet, grade and match every healthcare professional. No set-up fees.